South Dakota is a hidden gem for steak lovers, and I had the pleasure of indulging in some of the best steakhouses in the state. Each visit was a unique experience filled with mouthwatering dishes and warm hospitality that made me feel right at home.
From casual dining spots to upscale eateries, these 16 places served up unforgettable meals that I still crave. Join me on this delicious journey through the heart of South Dakota’s steak scene!
1. The Keg Steakhouse + Bar, Sioux Falls, US
What to Expect
The Keg Steakhouse + Bar is a gem nestled in the heart of Sioux Falls.
Known for its inviting atmosphere, it offers a delightful mix of steakhouse classics and innovative dishes.
You’ll find the ambiance warm and welcoming, perfect for family gatherings or casual dinners with friends.
What I Recommend to Order
When you visit, don’t miss out on the signature Keg Steak—it’s grilled to perfection and bursting with flavor!
- The seasoning is just right, leaving your taste buds dancing.
- For an appetizer, try the loaded baked potato—totally worth it!
What I Didn’t Like
One little hiccup was the wait time during my visit, especially on a busy evening. It took a while for my order to arrive, and I was left checking my watch.
Overview
Overall, The Keg Steakhouse + Bar makes for a memorable dining experience.
With a combination of hearty meals and a lively atmosphere, it stands out among Sioux Falls eateries.
If you crave well-prepared steak and a friendly vibe, this place should definitely be on your list!
2. Delmonico’s Steakhouse, Sioux Falls, US
Delmonico’s Steakhouse
If you’re hunting for a top-tier steakhouse in Sioux Falls, look no further than Delmonico’s Steakhouse. This chophouse offers a delightful menu featuring a variety of steaks and seafood, all served in a refined, white-tablecloth setting. Prepare for a memorable dining experience surrounded by elegant decor and a friendly atmosphere.
Why You Should Eat Here
Delmonico’s truly stands out with its exceptional service and commitment to quality. The staff is attentive and knowledgeable, ensuring you feel at home from the moment you walk in.
If you appreciate a nice ambiance for a special night out or a celebratory meal, this is the place to be. The combination of fine dining with a welcoming touch makes it my go-to spot.
What to Order
You absolutely cannot miss the filet mignon. It’s cooked to perfection, incredibly tender, and packs a flavor punch that will have you swooning for more. Pair it with their garlic mashed potatoes for a comforting complement. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you!
3. Minervas Sioux Falls US
Minervas in Sioux Falls
Minervas is a charming American grill located in the heart of Sioux Falls, offering a delightful blend of grilled fare and seafood in a sophisticated setting.
The atmosphere is elegant yet comfortable, making it perfect for both casual dinners and special occasions. You’ll immediately feel at home with their welcoming staff.
Why You Should Eat Here
The restaurant boasts a fabulous salad bar featuring an array of options, from fresh greens to cold cuts. I’m not saying their chocolate mousse is life-changing, but it might just redefine dessert for you!
The quality of food consistently impresses, with rave reviews on everything from ribeye to panna cotta.
What to Order
- Try the ribeye; it’s cooked to perfection and embodies rich flavors.
- Don’t miss the panna cotta for dessert—it’s a sweet end that leaves you dreaming!
4. Montana Mike’s Steakhouse, Rapid City, US
What to Expect
Montana Mike’s Steakhouse is a casual dining gem perfect for steak lovers.
Its ranch-style decor and inviting atmosphere make it a great spot for family meals or casual gatherings.
The service is warm and friendly, giving you that homey feeling while enjoying hearty American dishes.
What I Recommend to Order
You absolutely have to try their Flo’s Filet!
It’s cooked to perfection with just the right amount of seasoning and tenderness.
- Pair it with a side of their creamy mac & cheese or sweet potato fries — trust me, you won’t regret it!
- The portions are generous, so come hungry!
Overview
The only downside I noticed was that the quality can be a little inconsistent on certain nights, which is common in busy steakhouses.
But overall, Montana Mike’s delivers delicious meals that keep you coming back for more!
5. Outback Steakhouse, Rapid City, US
What to Expect
If you’re in Rapid City, Outback Steakhouse promises a boisterous Australian-themed dining experience. The vibe is lively, and the staff is friendly, creating an inviting atmosphere perfect for families and friends alike.
What I Recommend to Order
You absolutely must try the signature Bloomin’ Onion appetizer; it’s a crispy, flavorful delight! For the main course, their steak is a classic—just make sure to specify your cooking preference, as it can be hit or miss! If you’re adventurous, the lobster tail is also a fantastic choice.
What I Didn’t Like
<pHonestly, the service can be a bit inconsistent. Some diners have raved about their servers, while others experienced sluggish service. Just be prepared for the possibility of a wait.
Overview
Overall, Outback Steakhouse delivers a mix of good food and hearty laughs, especially if you’re lucky enough to have an exceptional server. Their bustling atmosphere contributes to a fun dining experience, making it a solid choice for steak lovers.
6. The Carrot Seed Kitchen Co., Sioux Falls, US
What to Expect
The Carrot Seed Kitchen Co. is a delightful haven for food lovers and kitchen enthusiasts alike.
It’s a bright and cheery space filled with local products, kitchen gadgets, and unique culinary treasures.
The warm and friendly staff are incredibly knowledgeable, ready to help you find the perfect item—do you have a specific dish in mind? They’ll likely have just the thing!
What I Recommend to Order
Make sure to check out their olive oil and vinaigrette bar. Sampling those delicious flavors is a must!
If you’re buying a gift, the local jams and fun kitchen gadgets will surely delight anyone. Want to impress your friends? Grab a novelty cookie cutter!
What I Didn’t Like
The only downside is that the shop can get a bit crowded, especially during weekends. Tough choices, right? With so much to choose from, it can be hard to decide!
Overview
The Carrot Seed Kitchen Co. is truly a gem in downtown Brookings.
With its exceptional selection and friendly atmosphere, it’s become a regular stop for anyone who enjoys cooking or gift shopping.
Trust me; once you visit, you’re bound to return!
7. Texas Roadhouse, Rapid City, US
What to Expect
Texas Roadhouse is a lively chain steakhouse that brings a Southwestern flair to classic American fare.
The atmosphere is always buzzing, making it perfect for families and groups looking for a fun dining experience.
You’ll be greeted by Texas-themed decor, along with a friendly vibe that makes everyone feel right at home.
What I Recommend to Order
If you’re wondering what to get, I highly recommend the Porterhouse steak.
It’s grilled to perfection, juicy, and full of flavor. Don’t forget to try it with their loaded mashed potatoes!
The hot buns with cinnamon butter are a delightful touch—nothing beats that combo!
What I Didn’t Like
I did notice a little inconsistency with the rolls; some were a bit overbaked during peak hours. But the service mostly makes up for it!
Overview
Overall, Texas Roadhouse in Rapid City is a fantastic spot for steak lovers. You’re in for hearty portions, great service, and a lively atmosphere that makes every meal special!
8. Cattleman’s Steakhouse, Pierre, US
Cattleman’s Steakhouse Overview
Cattleman’s Steakhouse in Pierre, South Dakota, is a true gem for steak lovers. The warm atmosphere combined with sawdust on the floor gives it a rustic charm. You won’t just eat here; you’ll feel like part of a family.
What to Expect
This place is buzzing with excitement, and don’t be surprised if you wait a bit—good things take time! Grab a drink and soak in the delightful aroma while you wait. The staff, including the lovely owner Cindy, make you feel right at home.
What I Recommend to Order
- The 8 oz steak is an absolute must-try—it’s seasoned to perfection and cooked just right.
- Don’t skip the chocolate cake; it’s rich and satisfying!
What I Didn’t Like
Although the steaks are delicious, I did notice a few sides could be more generous in portions.
9. Jacky’s Restaurant, Rapid City, US
What to Expect
Jacky’s Restaurant serves up delicious Cajun cuisine in a narrow, red-hued space adorned with jazz-themed decor.
The ambiance is upbeat, making it a delightful stop for anyone craving authentic flavors.
What I Recommend to Order
You absolutely can’t miss trying the gumbo; it’s packed with bold flavors that dance on your palate.
The homemade fried pickles? Yes, please! They are a delightful crunch that perfectly complements the meal.
What I Didn’t Like
During my visit, I found the plastic plates a bit underwhelming.
Also, the spice level might vary, so let your server know if you like it hot!
Overview
If you’re in the mood for Cajun food, Jacky’s is a gem in Rapid City. The friendly staff, especially Sharon, make every visit special.
Whether you’re indulging in a crab and shrimp boil or simply enjoying a lovely dessert, the experience is sure to please your taste buds.
10. Colton’s Steakhouse & Grill, Rapid City, US
What to Expect
Welcome to Colton’s Steakhouse & Grill, where steakhouse fare meets local game and fish!
The ambiance is charming, accented with dark wood and leather, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere that’s perfect for any occasion.
What I Recommend to Order
You simply must try the Tatanka Filet! It’s tender and juicy, grilled to perfection, and served with a side of creamy mashed potatoes that are simply divine.
And don’t skip dessert— the cheesecake with warm blueberry sauce is a delightful way to wrap up your meal.
What I Didn’t Like
To be honest, the salad was a bit pedestrian, so maybe skip that and save room for the main event!
Overview
Colton’s truly nails it with great service and hearty portions. The staff is friendly and attentive, making sure your experience feels special.
With its cozy vibe and delicious offerings, this place stands out in Rapid City’s culinary scene. If you’re in town, Colton’s is definitely worth a visit!
11. Furr’s Fresh Buffet, Rapid City, US
What to Expect
Furr’s Fresh Buffet in Rapid City is a delightful family-friendly dining experience that serves up a variety of comfort foods in a buffet style.
The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, perfect for gatherings or a casual meal by yourself.
What sets it apart is the sheer variety on offer—from hearty meats to fresh salads and desserts galore.
What I Recommend to Order
You can’t go wrong with their carved roast beef; it’s deliciously tender and packed with flavor.
Don’t skip the mashed potatoes—they’re creamy and the ideal companion to the beef.
Pair it with one of their famous desserts for a truly satisfying meal!
What I Didn’t Like
Sometimes the crowd can get a bit overwhelming, especially during peak hours, and finding a table may require some patience.
Overview
Furr’s Fresh Buffet stands out as a go-to spot for casual dining, offering diverse options that appeal to everyone.
Whether you’re with family, friends, or even dining solo, it’s hard not to enjoy all that Furr’s has to offer.
12. Kelsey’s Steakhouse, Watertown, US
What to Expect
Kelsey’s Steakhouse is a hidden gem in Watertown, NY, where cozy charm meets mouthwatering steaks.
The atmosphere reflects a perfect blend of casual dining with a touch of elegance, making it an inviting place for all occasions.
What I Recommend to Order
Make sure to try their signature ribeye steak! It’s cooked to perfection and seasoned just right—the flavors are out of this world!
Pair it with their loaded baked potato, and you’ll be in comfort food heaven.
What I Didn’t Like
On busy nights, service can be a tad slow. But hey, good things come to those who wait, right?
Overview
If you’re a steak lover, Kelsey’s Steakhouse is definitely a place you’ll want to experience.
Their commitment to quality and friendly service makes every bite special.
So why not treat yourself to a delightful evening filled with amazing food? You deserve it!
13. Buffalo Ridge Trading Post, Custer, US
What to Expect
Welcome to Buffalo Ridge Trading Post, the perfect gem nestled in Custer, where you’ll find a delightful mix of souvenirs and local treasures.
From the moment you walk in, the charming atmosphere embraces you, making it an unforgettable shopping experience.
What I Recommend to Order
You absolutely have to check out their soft tees—great for adventures, and they come in a range of sizes!
The hot sauces? Incredible! I mean, who doesn’t love a little spice in their life? Perfect for any palate!
What I Didn’t Like
Honestly, I wish I had more time to explore—there’s so much to see!
And believe me, I had to resist the urge to buy every cute bracelet in sight!
Overview
Buffalo Ridge Trading Post offers friendly service and unbeatable prices, making it a must-visit in Colorado Springs.
You’ll find unique souvenirs that capture the spirit of the area. Plus, the owner is just a delight!
If you’re in the area, it’s worth popping in to find that perfect memory of your trip!
14. Firehouse Brewing Co., Rapid City, US
What to Expect
Firehouse Brewing Co. is a fantastic gem set in a renovated firehouse.
The atmosphere is casual and lively, filled with firefighter memorabilia that adds a unique charm.
You’ll enjoy a menu boasting hearty pub grub and their own house-brewed beers—certainly a highlight!
What I Recommend to Order
If you’re there, don’t miss out on the Prime Rib; cooked to perfection and bursting with flavor!
The Firehouse Red Ale is a must-try too—it takes me straight back to cozy Irish pubs.
And for a fun twist, try their vegetarian Beyond Burgers, which can be customized to suit your taste.
What I Didn’t Like
I did wish my fish tacos had a bit more spicy kick to them.
The salad portion sizes were also a little on the small side for my dinner-loving heart!
Overview
Overall, Firehouse Brewing Co. is a delightful place for casual dining and good conversation.
With great service and a lively atmosphere, it’s definitely worth a visit if you’re in Rapid City!
15. The 1890 Grille, Hill City, US
The 1890 Grille
This charming eatery in Hill City is famed for its mouthwatering steaks and a warm, inviting atmosphere.
When you walk in, you feel like you belong. The rustic decor and friendly staff make it a perfect place to unwind.
Why You Should Eat Here
What sets The 1890 Grille apart is its commitment to quality. They focus on local ingredients and traditional grilling techniques that create flavors that linger on the palate.
Whether you’re visiting after a day of exploring or just grabbing a nice meal, you’ll leave with a satisfied smile.
What to Order
You can’t go wrong with their signature ribeye steak. Cooked to your liking, it’s tender and bursting with flavor!
The seasoning is perfect and complements the beautiful marbling of the meat. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you!
16. Parker’s Bistro, Sioux Falls, US
Parker’s Bistro: A Culinary Gem in Sioux Falls
Parker’s Bistro boasts an elegant vintage charm while serving upscale American fare in a historic building. This delightful restaurant is a true dining experience you won’t forget.
Why You Should Eat Here
From the moment you enter, you’ll feel the inviting ambiance that makes every meal feel special. The staff genuinely care about your experience, making you feel like a valued guest.
The seasonal menu is both exciting and diverse, with options that cater to all tastes. You’ll find everything from juicy steaks to exquisite seafood, all prepared to perfection.
What to Order
- Don’t miss the Steak Diane – it’s perfectly cooked and bursting with flavor.
- The Pavlova for dessert is a must-try; it’s the perfect sweet ending to your meal.
Each dish showcases the chef’s creativity and dedication, making Parker’s Bistro a must-visit spot in Sioux Falls!