Cracker-Topped Tuna Noodle Casserole

The best tuna noodle casserole I have eaten came out of a hotel pan in a church hall in Halifax, Nova Scotia, on a cold Friday in March. There was a line down the stairs and a kid taking two dollar bills in a margarine tub.

Old-Fashioned Tuna Noodle Casserole with Mushroom Cream Sauce and Buttery Cracker Crust

I had gone for the chowder. The chowder was fine. The casserole is the one I still think about.

The Friday Supper in Halifax

It was a Lenten parish supper in the North End, the kind that runs every Friday between Ash Wednesday and Easter and has done for longer than anyone in the room could pin down. Folding tables, a hymn book propped under one leg, somebody’s playlist of fiddle music coming out of a single speaker near the coffee urn.

A woman named Marilyn was running the serving line, and when I hesitated between the chowder and the pan with the gold crust she told me, flatly, that I had not come all that way to eat soup I could get anywhere. So I took the casserole.

It was nothing like the grey institutional thing I expected. The sauce was properly silky, the mushrooms had actual browned edges, and the noodles still had a bit of chew to them. The cracker crumbs on top had gone deep brown in patches where the butter pooled.

I went back for seconds and asked her what was in it. She said no soup can, and looked slightly offended that I had asked.

Four Hours with Marilyn and a Market Full of Mushrooms

She also taught a Saturday class, which is how I ended up at the Halifax Seaport Farmers’ Market the next morning at eight with six other people and one very loud tote bag of a teacher. The market tour was chaotic in the way good ones are. She pulled us past the bread stalls, made us smell three kinds of cremini, argued pleasantly with a cheese vendor about cheddar sharpness, and bought celery that she insisted was better there than anywhere else in the city.

Then four hours in a borrowed kitchen upstairs, making a bechamel and getting corrected on how we held the whisk. I burned my flour slightly on the first go. She made me start over, which was fair.

What she kept repeating was that the dish only fails in two places. The sauce and the noodles. Everything else is just assembly.

Tuna Noodle Casserole Is Older Than the Soup Can

I had always filed this as a 1950s invention, a product of station wagons and condensed soup. That is wrong, and Marilyn was right to be smug about it.

The earliest printed recipe turned up in Sunset Magazine in 1930, sent in by a reader listed as Mrs. W.F.S. of Kennewick, Washington, under the name Noodles and Tuna Fish en Casserole. It already had mushrooms in it and a cheese topping. Campbell’s did not launch condensed cream of mushroom soup until 1934, which means the original version was always a homemade white sauce with real mushrooms sauteed in butter. The soup can came later and made it faster, not more authentic.

The rest of the history is easy to see once you know it. Shelf-stable tuna and cheap noodles made it a rationing-era staple in the forties, and the meatless Friday tradition gave it a permanent place in Catholic parish kitchens. Which is exactly why I first ate it standing in a church basement during Lent, surrounded by people who had been eating it there since they were small.

Old-Fashioned Tuna Noodle Casserole with Mushroom Cream Sauce and Buttery Cracker Crust from the side

What I Used

  • Wide egg noodles, about 12 oz, boiled two minutes shy of the box
  • Unsalted butter, 6 tbsp, split between the mushrooms and the crumb topping
  • White or cremini mushrooms, 8 oz, sliced thin
  • One yellow onion, chopped small
  • Two stalks of celery, also chopped small
  • All-purpose flour, a third of a cup
  • Whole milk, 3 cups, warmed first
  • Sharp cheddar, 1.5 cups shredded, most of it into the sauce
  • Three 5 oz cans of solid white tuna in water, drained hard and flaked
  • Frozen peas, 1.5 cups, straight out of the bag
  • A tablespoon of fresh lemon juice
  • Salt, black pepper, and a scrape of nutmeg if you like it
  • Buttery round crackers, about 35 of them, crushed coarse

I buy the mushrooms at the Wednesday farmers’ market because the ones at the supermarket near me are always a little damp and they steam instead of browning. The cheddar I am less precious about. Any properly sharp block will do, as long as you grate it yourself, because the pre-shredded stuff has anti-caking powder in it and the sauce goes grainy.

Old-Fashioned Tuna Noodle Casserole with Mushroom Cream Sauce and Buttery Cracker Crust close up

Where Most Home Cooks Lose It

Noodles first. Boil them to package doneness and you have already lost, because they keep cooking in the oven for another half hour. Two minutes short, drained, left sitting in the colander, not rinsed. This single thing is the difference between the casserole people make fun of and the one Marilyn served.

Second is the tuna. Drain it like you mean it. Press the flesh against the lid with your thumb until nothing more runs out, or the water leaks into the sauce in the oven and you get a soupy bottom layer.

The sauce is the fussy bit and worth the fuss. Brown the mushrooms properly before anything else goes in, single layer, three minutes without touching them. Cook the flour for a full two minutes so it smells toasty rather than raw, then add the warm milk in three goes, whisking hard between each. The first time I made it at home I dumped all the milk in at once and spent ten minutes chasing lumps around the pan with a fork.

Season it slightly too aggressively off the heat. The noodles drink salt. And fold everything together gently, lifting from the bottom, or the tuna breaks into paste.

The Home Version, Rain and All

I made it on a Sunday evening in November with rain on the kitchen window and nothing much else going on. It is not the same. There is no fiddle music, no line down the stairs, no Marilyn telling me I have chosen wrong.

But it came out of the oven bubbling at the corners with the crumbs gone gold, and I ate it at the wooden table with a plate of sliced tomatoes and pickles, which is apparently what you do. Then I let it rest ten minutes first. I always rest it. Except when I do not, which is most of the time, and then it runs across the plate and I eat it anyway.

On swaps, crushed potato chips or corn flakes are both historically correct toppings and both excellent. Panko is modern and I think it looks wrong on this. Peas are traditional but plenty of old versions skip them entirely, so leave them out if you hate them.

It keeps three days and reheats covered at 350 F with a splash of milk stirred through. Cold leftovers, standing at the fridge. Honestly better than the first night.

Old-Fashioned Tuna Noodle Casserole with Mushroom Cream Sauce and Buttery Cracker Crust

Tuna Noodle Casserole

This is the version that came before canned soup: real mushrooms sauteed in butter, a silky milk sauce built from a roux, sharp cheddar melted through, and wide egg noodles pulled from the pot early so they never turn to mush. Flaked tuna and sweet peas fold in, a buttery cracker crust goes over the top, and it bakes until the edges bubble and the crumbs turn deep gold.
Prep Time 25 minutes
Cook Time 30 minutes
Total Time 55 minutes
Servings: 6 People
Course: Main Course
Cuisine: American
Calories: 560

Ingredients
  

  • 12 oz wide egg noodles
  • 6 tbsp unsalted butter divided
  • 8 oz white or cremini mushrooms sliced thin
  • 1 medium yellow onion finely chopped
  • 2 stalks celery finely chopped
  • 0.33 cup all-purpose flour
  • 3 cups whole milk warmed
  • 1.5 cups sharp cheddar cheese shredded, divided
  • 3 cans solid white tuna in water 5 oz each, drained very well and flaked
  • 1.5 cups frozen peas no need to thaw
  • 1 tbsp fresh lemon juice
  • 1.25 tsp salt to taste
  • 0.75 tsp black pepper freshly ground
  • 0.25 tsp ground nutmeg optional
  • 1.5 cups buttery round crackers coarsely crushed, about 35 crackers

Equipment

  • 1 9x13 inch baking dish buttered
  • 1 Large pot for the noodles
  • 1 Large Skillet for the sauce
  • 1 Colander
  • 1 Whisk

Method
 

  1. Heat the oven to 400 F and butter a 9x13 inch baking dish.
  2. Bring a large pot of well-salted water to a boil. Add the egg noodles and cook two minutes less than the package directions, so they are still firm at the center. Drain in a colander and leave them there; do not rinse.
  3. Melt 4 tablespoons of the butter in a large skillet over medium-high heat. Add the mushrooms in a single layer and cook without stirring for 3 minutes, then stir and cook 4 minutes more until browned and the liquid they released has cooked away.
  4. Add the onion and celery, lower the heat to medium, and cook 5 minutes until soft and translucent.
  5. Sprinkle the flour over the vegetables and stir constantly for 2 minutes. The mixture will look like wet sand and smell toasty.
  6. Pour in the warm milk in three additions, whisking hard after each until smooth before adding more. Simmer 4 to 5 minutes, whisking often, until the sauce coats the back of a spoon.
  7. Take the skillet off the heat. Stir in 1 cup of the cheddar until melted, then the lemon juice, salt, pepper and nutmeg. Taste and adjust the seasoning; it should taste slightly over-salted at this stage because the noodles will soak it up.
  8. Tip the drained noodles into the skillet along with the flaked tuna and frozen peas. Fold gently with a spatula, lifting from the bottom, just until everything is coated. Do not stir hard or the tuna will break down.
  9. Spread the mixture into the buttered dish and level the top. Scatter over the remaining 0.5 cup cheddar.
  10. Melt the remaining 2 tablespoons butter and toss it with the crushed crackers until the crumbs are evenly damp. Scatter them over the casserole in an even layer.
  11. Bake 25 to 30 minutes, until the sauce bubbles up at the edges and the crumbs are deep golden. If the top browns before the edges bubble, tent loosely with foil.
  12. Rest the casserole 10 minutes before serving. This lets the sauce set so it spoons out in clean portions instead of running.

Notes

  • Boil the noodles two minutes shy of the package time. They finish cooking in the oven, and this is the single thing that separates a good casserole from a mushy one.
  • Drain the tuna hard. Press it against the lid with your thumb until no more liquid runs out, or the sauce will thin in the oven.
  • Crushed potato chips or corn flakes work just as well as crackers for the topping. Panko is modern, not traditional.
  • Serve with a sharp green salad, buttered green beans or sliced tomatoes and pickles alongside.
  • Assemble up to a day ahead, refrigerate unbaked and un-topped, then add the crumbs and add 10 minutes to the bake time.
  • Leftovers keep 3 days refrigerated. Reheat covered at 350 F with a splash of milk stirred through.
  • Scroll to Top